Kindle edition · Stones Don't Lie Press
The Stones
Don't Lie
Twelve thousand years of history. The same mistake. The same collapse.
And an alternative that admits its own limits.
Kindle edition, in English. The paperback is coming soon. Spanish edition: Las Piedras No Mienten.
What is The Stones Don't Lie?
You work more hours than your grandfather. You live worse.
Twelve thousand years ago, people who had not yet invented agriculture raised the pillars of Göbekli Tepe. Nobody forced them. Nobody paid them. Then came the granary, the scribe and the ledger, and every system since has promised cooperation and delivered control.
This book follows that mechanism through Rome, feudal Europe, the factory, Cybersyn, and the algorithm that decides what your day is worth. The promise is always the same, and it breaks in the same place every time.
Then it stops diagnosing. The Ludist Manifesto borrows from the one arena where millions of people cooperate without anyone forcing them, which is multiplayer games. The last part turns that same skepticism on the proposal.
You are not asked to agree. You are asked to check.
Written from inside the corporations that build these systems, not from outside them.
The proposal
The Ludist Manifesto proposes societies designed around voluntary cooperation, drawing on principles from successful multiplayer games combined with real-world cases like Mondragón, Linux, and Rojava.
Why do societies collapse?
It's not bad luck. It's social physics. The same pattern, for 12,000 years.
The collapse formula
- Concentration of power in elites who control resources and decisions
- Maximum extraction of labor, resources, and energy from the population
- Minimum coordination among the people sustaining the system
- Inevitable collapse when the cost outweighs the benefit
Indus Valley
A civilization without standing armies. Centralizing trade reduced its resilience. It collapsed when climate shifted and the system couldn't bend.
Imperial Rome
Provinces drained to sustain elites. Citizens stopped cooperating once the military cost of belonging to the empire exceeded the benefits.
Göbekli Tepe
The first monumental ritual center, predating agriculture. Massive collective labor — then deliberately abandoned and buried.
"Maximum extraction. Minimum coordination."
Capitalism and socialism — theoretically opposed — collapse for the same reason. Both are systems of forced cooperation.
Sign up for the Stone Papers and news
What's inside the book?
27 chapters · 5 parts
Part I: Evidence from the Past (Chs. 1–16)
Sixteen chapters: 12,000 years of social systems from the Paleolithic to the present.
The book's longest historical sweep: 40,000 BCE through today, including diagnoses of neoliberalism, total surveillance, and current demographic/geopolitical fractures. Not pop history — pattern analysis of collapse.
Documented cases: Paleolithic, Neolithic Revolution, Mesopotamia/Egypt, China/Indus Valley, Greece/Rome, Mesoamerica, Middle Ages, Renaissance, Industrial Revolution, 20th century (including secret state experiments), global neoliberalism, contemporary panopticon, fractures of the present.
Part II: Comparative Synthesis (Chs. 17–18)
Universal patterns extracted from 12,000 years of evidence.
Why opposing civilizations collapse for the same reasons. The patterns of collapse, their diagnoses, and the possible exits. The universal mechanisms of control that reappear in every era.
Part III: Principles and Possibilities (Chs. 19–20)
The six principles validated by 12,000 years of evidence.
Identifies which design elements work consistently — and lays out the methodological frame for rigorous social experimentation.
Cases analyzed: Mondragón (80,000-person cooperative), Linux (global infrastructure with no owner), Wikipedia (voluntary collaboration at scale), Rojava (horizontal governance, 4M people), Kerala (participatory budgeting, 35M people), Rochdale (active since 1844).
Part IV: The Ludist Manifesto (Chs. 21–24)
The concrete proposal, with detailed mechanics.
Specific and testable: XP (objective contribution), SP (peer recognition), Rotating Committees, Auditable AI, and Symmetric Surveillance. Not abstract theory — includes success and failure metrics.
Radical honesty:
"I'd take auditable inefficiency over opaque efficiency with existential risk." The Manifesto names the problems it does not solve. It isn't recruiting converts — it's looking for experimenters.
Part V: Critique and Limits (Chs. 25–27)
"Four chapters building it. Now it's time to tear it down."
Three chapters dedicated to dismantling the book's own proposal: the limits of the technique, the limits of human nature, and what remains unresolved. What sets this book apart from other utopian proposals: the self-critique is part of the design.
The Unsolved Problems
Part V works through them one by one. They aren't bugs — they're the heart of the debate.
The analysis lives in the book. These are the problems.
The AI Problem
The Manifesto depends on an AI that doesn't exist. It assumes capabilities the most heavily funded industry on the planet hasn't solved, and building on that is building on sand.
The Goodhart Problem
When the metric becomes the target, it stops measuring what it measured. XP and SP can be gamed.
The Scaling Problem
Coordination beyond Dunbar scale breaks down differently than coordination within it. Trust degrades as scale climbs.
Factions Are Inevitable
Groups form over nothing. And where everyone rates everyone, alliances aren't a flaw in the design but its expected behaviour.
The Capture Problem
Rotation does stop blatant capture. What's left is subtler: the bias moves to which options get presented, and human judgement becomes a formality when questioning is costly and accepting is easy.
The Fatigue Problem
The Swiss vote four times a year and average 45% turnout. It isn't apathy: informed participation competes with life, and loses.
The Surveillance Problem
Symmetric transparency creates retaliation surfaces. Seeing everyone also means everyone sees you.
"Look for the flaws. They're probably where my biases keep me from seeing them."
— The Stones Don't Lie, Ch. 26
What makes this book different?
This book IS:
- ✓ A rigorous analysis of thousands of years of social experiments
- ✓ Honest about its limits and unsolved problems
- ✓ A testable proposal with success and failure metrics
- ✓ An invitation to responsible experimentation
This book is NOT:
- ✗ The perfect utopia that will solve everything
- ✗ A dogmatic prescription of "the one solution"
- ✗ A permanent fix (it admits it will also collapse)
- ✗ Gaming escapism without serious historical analysis
Who is this book for?
For experimenters, not converts. For people who can see that the current system is collapsing and want to explore honest alternatives.
- • You work more hours than your parents did and live worse
- • You wonder why institutions and democracies don't deliver what they promise
- • You've seen voluntary cooperation actually work — in online communities or open-source projects
- • You want specific, testable alternatives, not abstract theory
You don't have to be a gamer. But it helps if you can see that some digital systems solve cooperation problems better than institutions with centuries of history.
Independent. No sponsors.
Like the work? Buy me a coffee.
Books take years. If any part of this project has already been useful to you, a coffee helps keep the research going — for the current title, the next one, and the free Stone Papers series.
Buy me a coffeePay what you want. One-time or monthly. Hosted at buymeacoffee.com.
